Shop Local for the Best Last-Minute Valentine’s Gifts in Staunton, VA

Valentine’s Day is about love in all its forms—romance, friendship, and the connections that make life richer. But in a world where it’s easy to feel disconnected, the best gifts are the ones that bring us closer. Whether you’re celebrating a sweetheart, a best friend, or yourself, the American Shakespeare Center’s Valentine’s Gift Guide has something that will make them feel truly seen.

(from left to right: Hailey Pearce & Jake Raiter at the Blackfriars Playhouse Gift Shop. Photo by Alaina Shefelton.)

Find the perfect gift right here in Staunton, VA, at the Blackfriars Playhouse Gift Shop, which is stocked with witty, Shakespeare-inspired merch you won’t find anywhere else, from cozy apparel to clever keepsakes. Shopping for someone far away? Give the gift of live theatre with tickets or an ASC e-gift card—a thoughtful last-minute option with virtual delivery.

Now, let’s dive into nine unique gifts that will make any theatre or literature lover’s heart skip a beat—on Valentine’s Day, Galentine’s Day, or just because.

​ASC’s Valentine Gift Guide

For the Star-Cross’d Romantic  Read My Lips Romeo & Juliet Lip Balm – A pear of star-cross’d lovers flavor! This moisturizing balm has all the nourishing ingredients that make it a year-round favorite—plus an unexpected twist. Unroll the wrapper to reveal a hidden literary label filled with a little poetry, a little whimsy, and a little drama. A perfect gift for the romantic (or the theatre lover who just loves a good reveal).
For the One Who Knows Their Worth Henry V Self-Love Compact Mirror – “Self-love is not so vile a sin as self-neglecting.” This sleek, pocket-sized compact is perfect for quick touch-ups and confidence boosts alike. With two mirrors—one true-to-life and one with 2x magnification for those larger-than-life moments—it’s a daily reminder to own your brilliance. A must-have for anyone who believes in the power of self-love (with a little Shakespearean flair).
For the One Who Thinks Passion and Theatre Should Never Fade to Black  “We Do It With the Lights On” Crewneck – Some things are better in the dark—but theatre (and passion) isn’t one of them. This ridiculously cozy, audaciously cheeky crewneck is a bold nod to ASC’s Shared Light tradition and the perfect way to turn up the heat this Valentine’s Day. Whether you’re a die-hard Shakespeare fan, a lover of wordplay, or just someone who likes to make a statement, this sweater keeps things warm, witty, and totally lit.
For the One Who Thrives on Drama, Not Romance Tickets to King Lear – Love stories are nice, but sometimes you just want betrayal, ambition, and a kingdom in chaos. With treachery at every turn and a storm that shakes the world, King Lear is Shakespeare at his most gripping—no grand romances, just power struggles, shifting alliances, and a family feud for the ages. Opening February 15—because not every Valentine’s gift needs a love story.
For the One Who’s as Cozy as They Are Cute ASC Yellow Beanie – The best Valentine’s gifts keep you warm—whether it’s love, friendship, or the perfect beanie. This bright, cozy ASC beanie is made for the Valentine or Galentine who’s always bringing the sunshine (even in February). Cute, comfy, and effortlessly cool—just like them.
For the Prickly but Lovable Friend  Shakespeare Bust Planter – Some people are all sharp edges, but deep down, they’ve got plenty of heart (and maybe a soft spot for greenery). This Shakespeare bust planter is perfect for the friend who’s a little thorny but still thrives in the right conditions—just like a well-loved houseplant.
For the One Who Knows Love Is Bigger Than Romance Tickets to Little Women (Feb 14) – Some love stories aren’t about grand gestures—they’re about the unshakable bonds of sisterhood, friendship, and found family. Whether it’s the fierce love between the March sisters, the slow-burning connection between Jo and Professor Bhaer, or the steadfast devotion of Meg and Brooke, Little Women is a Valentine’s celebration of all the ways we love and are loved. Perfect for a romantic date, a Galentine’s night out, or anyone who believes that love—in all its forms—deserves the spotlight.
For the Gal Who Knows Her Heartbreak Anthems by Heart  Henry VIII & His Disappearing Wives Mug – Divorced, beheaded, died… but never forgotten. If your Galentine can belt every word of Six and loves a little royal drama with her morning coffee, this heat-sensitive mug is the perfect gift. Just add a hot beverage and watch as Henry VIII’s six wives disappear. Because sometimes, love is fleeting—but good tea (and great friendships) are forever.
For the One Who Loves to Share Experiences  ASC Gift Card – The best gifts aren’t just things—they’re moments shared. Whether it’s seeing a show, picking out the perfect Playhouse souvenir, or exploring ASC in a new way, an ASC gift card lets them choose their own adventure. Plus, they can be purchased online and emailed instantly—so distance is never an issue when sharing the love of theatre.

Give a Gift Worthy of a Standing Ovation 

Forget fleeting flowers and predictable chocolates—this Valentine’s, give a gift with character. Whether you’re celebrating romance, friendship, or a love for great storytelling, these hand-picked gifts bring theatre, literature, and history to life with a touch of wit and a whole lot of heart.

Shop in person at the Blackfriars Playhouse Gift Shop for Shakespeare-inspired merch and literary treasures, or send tickets and e-gift cards online for an experience they’ll never forget. With digital delivery straight to their inbox, it’s an effortless way to make your favorite theatre lover swoon.

Because the best gifts spark joy, start conversations, and stand the test of time. Make this Valentine’s (or Galentine’s!) one to remember with something as bold, timeless, and unforgettable as they are.